Ready to lace up and find your perfect running companion? The world of running shoes is vast, with countless options promising comfort, performance, and style. Choosing between two of the most popular brands, On Cloud and Brooks, can be a tough decision.
This in-depth comparison dives into the core features of both, helping you understand their strengths and weaknesses. We’ll explore everything from cushioning and support to durability and design. Whether you’re a seasoned marathoner or a casual jogger, this guide is designed to help you discover the ideal shoe for your individual needs.
Get ready to analyze the pros and cons of the On Cloud and Brooks lineup. We’ll break down the key differences, helping you make an informed choice. By the end, you’ll be one step closer to finding the perfect running shoe.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | On Cloud | Brooks |
|---|---|---|
| Cushioning | CloudTec® | DNA LOFT |
| Heel Drop | 6-8 mm | 8-12 mm |
| Midsole Material | Helion™ Superfoam | DNA LOFT |
| Upper Material | Engineered Mesh | Engineered Mesh |
| Weight (approx.) | Moderate | Moderate |
| Stability | Neutral | Varies |
| Best Use | Road Running, Everyday Wear | Road Running |
| Outsole | CloudTec® | Rubber |
| Arch Support | Neutral | Neutral to Supportive |
| Durability | Good | Good |
| Breathability | Good | Good |
| Flexibility | Flexible | Flexible |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Cushioning
- On Cloud: CloudTec technology provides a unique cushioning experience with individual “clouds” that compress upon impact. This offers a responsive and adaptable feel, ideal for shorter runs and everyday wear. However, some runners may find the cushioning less plush compared to traditional models.
- Brooks: Brooks offers a range of cushioning technologies like DNA LOFT, BioMoGo DNA, and DNA Flash, catering to various preferences. These provide a more traditional and generally plusher feel, suitable for both short and long distances. The specific feel varies depending on the Brooks model.
- Winner: Brooks
Responsiveness
- On Cloud: The CloudTec elements contribute to a responsive feel, especially in newer models with Speedboard technology. This helps with a snappy toe-off, making it suitable for speed work and tempo runs. Some find it less responsive than dedicated racing flats.
- Brooks: Responsiveness varies based on the model and cushioning technology. DNA Flash in particular offers a highly responsive experience. Brooks shoes generally provide a good balance of responsiveness and cushioning.
- Winner: On Cloud
Weight
- On Cloud: On Cloud shoes are generally lightweight, contributing to their appeal for everyday wear and shorter runs. The specific weight varies by model.
- Brooks: Brooks shoes range in weight depending on the model and intended use. Some Brooks models are quite lightweight, while others prioritize durability and cushioning, resulting in a slightly heavier feel.
- Winner: On Cloud
Durability
- On Cloud: The durability of On Cloud shoes can vary. Some users report that the CloudTec elements can wear down more quickly, particularly with heavy use or on abrasive surfaces.
- Brooks: Brooks shoes are known for their durability. The outsoles and uppers are generally built to withstand regular wear and tear, making them a good choice for runners who log significant mileage.
- Winner: Brooks
Stability
- On Cloud: On Cloud shoes offer varying levels of stability, depending on the model. Some models are designed with features to enhance stability, while others are geared towards neutral runners.
- Brooks: Brooks offers a wide range of stability shoes, with technologies like GuideRails to help control pronation and provide support for overpronators.
- Winner: Brooks
Fit and Comfort
- On Cloud: On Cloud shoes often feature a snug and streamlined fit, with a focus on a modern aesthetic. Comfort levels are generally good, but some runners may find the fit restrictive.
- Brooks: Brooks shoes are known for their comfortable and accommodating fit, often offering a range of widths. They prioritize a secure and comfortable feel for various foot shapes.
- Winner: Brooks
Aesthetics
- On Cloud: On Cloud shoes are known for their distinctive and stylish design, with a focus on modern aesthetics and a sleek silhouette. They are often seen as a fashionable choice.
- Brooks: Brooks shoes have a more classic running shoe look, with a focus on function and performance. While designs are improving, they might not be as visually striking as some other brands.
- Winner: On Cloud
Price
- On Cloud: On Cloud shoes tend to be positioned at a higher price point compared to some other brands, reflecting their premium materials and design.
- Brooks: Brooks shoes are generally available at a more accessible price point, offering good value for the performance and durability they provide.
- Winner: Brooks
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Cushioning Feel | On Cloud |
| Style | On Cloud |
| Support | Brooks |
| Stability Options | Brooks |
| Traditional Feel | Brooks |
What They Have in Common:
- Upper Material: Both shoes utilize engineered mesh uppers, providing breathability and a comfortable fit for the runner. This material helps to keep your feet cool and dry during runs.
- Road Running Focus: Both brands are primarily designed for road running, catering to a wide range of runners and distances. They both offer great performance on pavement.
- Comfort: Both brands prioritize comfort in their designs, aiming to provide a pleasant running experience. This includes well-cushioned midsoles and supportive uppers.
- Durability: Both shoes are built with durable materials, ensuring they can withstand the rigors of regular running. You can expect a good lifespan from both brands.
- Breathability: Both shoes boast good breathability, which is essential for keeping your feet cool and comfortable during runs, especially in warmer weather. This feature helps prevent overheating.
On Cloud Vs Brooks Buying Guide
Comfort and Fit
Both On Cloud and Brooks offer comfortable running shoes, but they approach comfort differently. On Cloud shoes are known for their unique CloudTec technology, which provides a cushioned and responsive feel. The fit tends to be snug, hugging the foot for a secure feel. Brooks, on the other hand, often prioritizes a more traditional, plush feel with ample cushioning. Their shoes generally offer a wider toe box, accommodating various foot shapes. Consider trying on both brands to determine which fit and comfort level best suits your needs.
The choice between On Cloud and Brooks often comes down to personal preference regarding cushioning and fit. On Cloud’s design is known for a unique feel, while Brooks provides a more familiar experience.
Cushioning and Support
Cushioning and support are vital aspects to consider when selecting running shoes. On Cloud shoes feature CloudTec technology, which offers a unique cushioning experience. These “clouds” compress upon impact, providing a responsive feel. Brooks shoes, like the Glycerin or Adrenaline series, often incorporate their DNA LOFT cushioning, providing a softer, more traditional feel. Brooks are known for their stability features, which are especially helpful for overpronation.
Assess your running style and foot needs. If you crave a responsive feel, On Cloud might be a good fit. If you prefer a more traditional, plush feel with added stability, Brooks could be the better choice. (See Also: New Balance 9060 Vs 530: In-depth Comparison and Review)
Durability and Longevity
The durability and longevity of running shoes are essential factors for value. On Cloud shoes, while providing a unique experience, can sometimes exhibit less durability in the CloudTec elements, particularly with frequent use on rough terrains. The outsole can wear down faster compared to some other brands. Brooks generally offers robust outsoles and midsoles, known for their longevity, especially in their popular models.
Consider the surfaces you’ll be running on and your mileage. If you run primarily on smooth surfaces, On Cloud may be fine. For tougher terrains and higher mileage, Brooks might offer better durability.
Performance and Running Style
On Cloud shoes are often favored for their responsiveness and are suitable for various running styles. They are especially good for speedwork and shorter distances. Their design encourages a midfoot strike. Brooks shoes are known for their versatility, catering to neutral and stability runners. They offer models suitable for daily training, long runs, and even racing. Brooks are great for a variety of running needs.
Consider your training goals and running style. If you prioritize speed and responsiveness, On Cloud could be a good choice. If you need a versatile shoe for all types of runs, Brooks might be more suitable.
Price and Value
The price of running shoes varies, and both On Cloud and Brooks offer options at various price points. On Cloud shoes are generally positioned in the premium price range, reflecting their innovative technology and design. Brooks shoes often provide a more accessible entry point, offering competitive features at a slightly lower price. However, prices vary depending on the specific model and features offered.
Evaluate your budget and the features you need. While On Cloud offers innovative technology, Brooks often provides excellent value for its price, especially if you prioritize durability and versatility. (See Also: Top 10 Best Winter Shoes for Dogs: a Comprehensive Review)
Aesthetics and Design
Aesthetics play a role in shoe selection, and both brands offer different design philosophies. On Cloud is known for its distinctive and modern aesthetic, with a sleek profile and visible CloudTec elements. They often feature bold color combinations and a contemporary look. Brooks shoes often prioritize a more classic and understated design, with a focus on functionality and comfort. They offer a wide range of colors and styles.
Consider your personal style and preferences. If you want a shoe with a modern, eye-catching design, On Cloud might be appealing. If you prefer a more classic and versatile look, Brooks may be a better fit.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy On Cloud If…
- You prefer a shoe with a unique CloudTec® cushioning system for a distinctive feel.
- You value a stylish and modern design, suitable for both running and everyday wear.
- You are looking for a shoe that offers a balance of cushioning and responsiveness.
- You prefer a lighter-weight running shoe.
Buy Brooks If…
- You prioritize consistent and reliable performance in a traditional running shoe.
- You need a shoe with a supportive fit and good arch support.
- You prefer a well-cushioned shoe for longer distances.
- You are seeking a shoe with a wider range of stability options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is CloudTec technology, and how does it work?
CloudTec technology is the core of On Cloud shoes, consisting of individual “clouds” on the sole. These clouds compress upon impact, providing cushioning and a responsive feel. They then spring back to propel you forward. This design aims to provide a unique running experience, offering both impact absorption and energy return. It is designed to create a cushioned landing.
Are Brooks shoes good for runners with flat feet?
Yes, Brooks offers several models that are well-suited for runners with flat feet. The Brooks Adrenaline GTS series is a popular choice, providing excellent support and stability for overpronation. These shoes often incorporate features like GuideRails to help align the foot and promote a more neutral stride. Check for models with pronation control.
How do I determine my shoe size for On Cloud shoes?
It’s generally recommended to consult On Cloud’s size chart, as sizing can vary slightly between brands and models. It’s often helpful to measure your foot length and compare it to their size guide. Consider trying on the shoes in a store if possible to ensure a proper fit, as their fit can sometimes run small. Consider the width too.
What is the typical lifespan of a pair of running shoes?
The lifespan of a pair of running shoes typically ranges from 300 to 500 miles, depending on the shoe’s construction, running style, and the terrain. The cushioning and support will degrade over time, affecting performance and potentially increasing the risk of injury. Keep track of your mileage and replace your shoes when they start to feel worn out. (See Also: Best Shoes for Restaurant Workers: Non-Slip & Comfortable)
Are On Cloud shoes good for beginners?
Yes, On Cloud shoes can be a good option for beginners, particularly those seeking a responsive and comfortable ride. However, it’s essential to consider your individual needs. The unique CloudTec technology might take some getting used to. Beginners can benefit from the cushioned feel and should focus on finding a fit that feels comfortable. Consider other options too.
What are the key differences between neutral and stability running shoes?
Neutral running shoes are designed for runners with a neutral gait, providing cushioning and flexibility. Stability shoes are designed for runners who overpronate (foot rolls inward excessively), offering features that help control excessive motion and provide support. Stability shoes often have firmer materials on the medial side of the shoe.
How do I care for my running shoes to extend their lifespan?
To extend the lifespan of your running shoes, avoid washing them in a washing machine, as this can damage the materials. Instead, clean them by hand with mild soap and water. Allow them to air dry away from direct sunlight and heat. Rotate between multiple pairs of shoes to give each pair time to recover. Properly store shoes.
Final Verdict
Both On Cloud and Brooks offer excellent running shoes, each with unique strengths. On Cloud shines with its innovative CloudTec technology, providing a responsive and modern feel, making it suitable for those who crave a unique running experience and aesthetic appeal. Brooks, with its focus on classic comfort, support, and a broader range of models, often appeals to a wider audience, especially those seeking stability and a versatile shoe for various running needs.
Choosing between the two depends on individual preferences, running style, and priorities. While On Cloud has innovative elements, Brooks offers a reliable choice.
Winner: Brooks